Engineering Labs: An Efficiency Opportunity
February 28th, 2011 By: Rich Miller
As America’s largest companies begin to get a handle on their data center energy usage, they’re widening their gaze to scrutinize the efficiency of their engineering labs. Managers of some of the leading lab operations in Silicon Valley say the attention is long overdue, and will lead to significant energy savings.
“One of my challenges is to carry the message that the lab is just as much a production environment is the data center, and should be treated as such,” said Val Sokolov, Senior Manager for Engineering Lab Services at Brocade Communications. “It’s not adequately understood up the channel.”
An Area of Opportunity
“The lab space is an area of opportunity,” said Mark Honer, Service Manager, Customer Service Labs at Juniper Networks. “It’s coming into its own.”
Sokolov and Honer discussed energy efficiency in labs, along with Cisco Systems Lab Manager Chris Noland, at last week’s Technology Convergence Conference in Santa Clara, Calif. Session moderator Mark Thiele of ServiceMesh jokingly noted that the panel featured speakers from Cisco, Brocade and Jumiper at the same table – “and no one’s strangling anyone.”
But the opportunities for energy savings are serious business. “Labs can constitute a major portion of your IT spend,” said Thiele, but tend to get scant attention from industry groups.
One possible reason: labs can be a more unruly environment than the data center, with disparate projects sharing space. “You have a massive amount of projects,” said Brocade’s Sokolov, which placse a premium on tracking and managing the equipment for each team as project cycles spin up and down.
Honer said that while a data center is supported by a staff of 20 to 30, laboratory environments can be used by 200 or 300 people at a time.
Need to Standardize
Having multiple project teams sharing space also mandates a focus on labeling and standardization. “You’ve never been in a more frustrating meeting than talking about what color cabling to use,” said Honer. “But when you move from lab to lab, you’re going to have problems without standardization.”
Labs are also often housed in legacy facilities rather than cutting edge data center space. “We’ve got labs that are designed around 35 watts per square foot in apps that want 500 watts per square foot,” said Honer. “Five years or 10 years ago, you wouldn’t have predicted. You have to constantly recycle and upgrade your labs to keep up with technology.”
“We’ve had everything from 35 watts a square-foot with cold air blowing everywhere right up to hot and cold aisle environments with curtains for containment,” said Cisco’s Noland.
‘People Have Woken Up’
But labs are now being sharing space in data center expansion projects. Noland says Cisco is building a “showcase” engineering lab featuring rack-top chimney containment systems. Last year Brocade consolidated its labs in a brand-new state-of-the-art data center at the company’s new campus in San Jose.
“In the last year or so, people have woken up and seen the lab as a strategic part of the company,” said Jupiter’s Honer. “This is a continuous evolution.”
This is a great topic. Labs are tremendous consumers of energy and often fall under the radar. Approx 75% of Cisco’s power bill is due to labs, I think.
Take a look here at a case study on the Cisco.com site that is directly relevant – http://www.cisco.com/en/US/solutions/collateral/ns340/ns517/ns224/casestudy_adinfa.pdf
>30% energy consumption savings, sub year RoI, automated monitoring and reporting, acocuntability – why wouldn’t you do it?
Nice coverage. I believe you have hit upon a topic that needs further discussion industry-wide. People just assume that labs are necessary and don’t fall under the same scrutiny as production systems. Even when labs are part of an overall virtualization component, they can still use a huge amount of energy, particularly when virtual sprawl comes into play. This makes it even more important to plan ahead and plan appropriately. Folks like 1E (http://www.1e.com) can help identify waste for the datacenter even before it is implemented utilizing NightWatchman Server Edition.
It’s funny how sometimes the elephant in the room is forgotten, so congrats on highlighting a topic that most people don’t even think about or consider worthy of making energy efficient.
Our product allows companies to use the existing space on their hard drives to provide backup to the complete enterprise network, so rather than using server farms you can make the most of your existing infrastructure.
I’d be keen to hear from the experts about how much energy the backups of the labs consume! Any thoughts?